Adaptive Leadership for Nonprofits: A Case Study in Effective Change-Making

November 8, 2024

For nonprofit leaders, adapting to changing conditions is about keeping the core mission of the organization on track while trying new strategies.

Adaptive Leadership: A Case Study

This kind of leadership requires adaptive capacity, defined as “the ability to adapt to changed circumstances while fulfilling one’s core purpose,” and it’s “an essential skill in an age of unforeseeable disruption and volatility” by Andrew Zolli and Ann Marie Healy.

An excellent case study in adaptive capacity comes from the nonprofit Corner of Love, which had to adapt due to political violence and instability in its home country of Nicaragua. Though circumstances in this case are dramatic, we hope the lessons learned will help you increase the adaptive capacity of your organization as you seek to transform the communities you work in.

Background: Tanya and Nelson Amador founded Corner of Love in 1992 to provide health care in rural Nicaragua. Nelson had grown up in San Ramon, a village in Nicaragua. After meeting Tanya in the U.S. and starting their family, they relocated to Nelson’s hometown to carry out the work of providing physical and spiritual nurture. They coordinated teams of medical professionals and volunteers who ran mobile clinics and built up the local communities of care. After several decades in San Ramon, the ministry was well established, with the equipment and infrastructure to provide a high level of care.

Change and Disruption: In 2018, political disruption and violence in Nicaragua intensified as the government became increasingly authoritarian. Nonprofits, church groups, and public universities were seen as threats to the control of the regime: more than 5,000 have been forced to close and some of their leaders were unjustly imprisoned. Tanya and Nelson began to fear for their safety when one of the officials who regulated their work was implicated in local gun violence. They packed a few bags hoping to return soon to their home and work. But they were unable to return, becoming two of the 700,000 Nicaraguans (10% of the country’s total population) who fled between 2018-2023 due to political violence and economical instability.

Adaptive Pivot: Tanya and Nelson wanted to continue the good work they had started, but faced daunting challenges. Their ministry had been location specific. They lost access to all their equipment. Their employees were either still in Nicaragua or had also become refugees. They decided to resettle in Costa Rica, where many other Nicaraguan refugees had fled. They set up new headquarters in a  restaurant near the Nicaraguan border, and they began the work of starting over. Instead of mobile clinics, they brought patients to the restaurant site by bus. Intake interviews were conducted in the dining room, examinations happened in a screened off area. A supply closet became the pharmacy. Dental work and supply distribution were done out of storage containers. In tandem with these pivots, plans were drawn up to build an actual clinic on the property.

Lessons for Nonprofit Leaders

Tanya shared some best practices that increased their adaptive capacity. 

Emotionally and mentally accepting the change is important.

“There were a lot of tears, especially at night,” Tanya said. “There was a gradual acceptance that we can’t go back. We were starting out barehanded. How do you recreate what you had?” Tanya talked about the importance of scaling down the work to match the reduction in resources. They had to consider what they could do with the limited supplies they had. “Your brain keeps going back to how it was–we had to retrain our brains to be okay with what we had.” Getting started with what they did have, diving into the work, helped them accept this new normal.

 

Use your core purpose as a compass while you remap the needs of those you serve.

In choosing a new location, they considered their core mission: healthcare to Nicaraguans in need. So they listened and learned where the refugees who were physically injured were relocating to, and they set up services there. Corner of Love increased the scope of its work to meet the more immediate needs of the refugees but kept its core mission. Tanya said, “People were so hungry and suddenly we were giving out so much food and meals. That was not who we had been. We could have turned into a ministry to feed the poor. That’s not our end goal, not really who we are. Healthcare is our strength and who we are, and we knew that was going to be needed–but we also knew we needed to feed people at first.”

Leaders need to be more hands-on in times of change.

Prior to the pivot, the nonprofit had a strong infrastructure and identity that allowed Tanya and Nelson to do a lot of delegating. Starting over required them to increase their presence and leadership. “There is no substitute for being right there with the team,” Tanya said. “When you pivot, you become vulnerable to losing the mission. We had a lot of new employees and participants; if we hadn’t been hands-on again, it would have been detrimental to keeping the core mission.”

Diversify Your Base.

“It’s super important to diversify your base and have friends and supporters of all walks of life,” Tanya said. The pivot required different kinds of support, and the couple had to reevaluate some assumptions as support came in from organizations that they thought would not get behind faith-based work. “In our darkest hours sometimes our biggest supporters were a surprise to me.”

Expect Big Changes.

“If you operate long enough, you will face some kind of a crisis where your mission has to be portable. Areas have hurricanes, earthquakes, government problems, pandemics. You can’t really prepare yourself for what we went through, but you could hold loosely the sense of access you need. Think more about portability and scale.”

Results of the Adaptive Pivot

Currently, Corner of Love is working in Costa Rica and the United States, focusing on the needs of displaced families. They serve more than 30,000 refugees annually by providing services through a refugee relief center with medical, dental, and optical clinics; home visitation to vulnerable families; and a nutrition and education program. 

The Center for Transforming Engagement seeks to advance the art of community building by creating innovative pathways for meaningful Impact and changing the narrative around faith-based community building. We offer workshops, training, and resilience groups for teams and individuals.

 

Upcoming Virtual Summit: Leading During Polarizing Times

Designed to help ministry leaders navigate the stress, fear, and uncertainty around holding extreme differences during this challenging time. Click below to learn more and register!

Upcoming Events

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Upcoming Virtual Summit
Leading During Polarizing Times
This FREE online event is designed for ministry leaders seeking practical tools, spiritual wisdom, and renewed strength to lead faithfully when your church community faces deep differences.
Upcoming Virtual Summit
Leading During Polarizing Times
This FREE online event is designed for ministry leaders seeking practical tools, spiritual wisdom, and renewed strength to lead faithfully when your church community faces deep differences.
Full attendance and participation during all sessions are expected to complete the program.
Terms / Conditions. By registering for a Resilience or Leaders Circle, you agree to the following (scroll down and click agree)
Please consider the schedule closely to ensure you will be able to participate in the virtual meetings, and block off your calendar to ensure your attendance. Should you have an emergency (illness, situations out of your control) that will impact your participation please email transforming@theseattleschool.edu
Time commitment:
Two hours one day per month for 8 months, dates to be determined by majority of registrants' availability and adjusted as needed during the first group meeting.
Your feedback is immensely valuable!
As an essential component of your participation in this program, we ask that you provide us with your honest, candid, and timely feedback in program surveys and conversations, and consider providing reviews or testimonials of the program for promotional use.
Code of Conduct:
The Center for Transforming Engagement strives for intentionality in the ways we relate to one another - how we as a team relate to each other, how we relate to participants, and how we hope participants will relate to us and one another. To that end, we hold cultural norms about the ways we interact with one another. Your participation in this program is contingent on your agreement to abide by these cultural norms. i. For growth to happen, we all need to be able to share about the deeper challenges we face. To provide that atmosphere of openness and support, you commit to not sharing personal information that is shared in program meetings. ii. In our interactions with each other and our communities, we practice the humility of not-knowing that is required to listen and discover. iii. Be aware of different cultural and characterological ways of communicating, and invite others’ voices. Respect theological differences: the river of Christian orthodoxy is wide, and while the streams of that river are distinct, they are not inherently better or worse. Even if you can’t respect the belief, treat the person with respect. iiii. We value both thoughts and feelings as valuable pieces of information that inform one another, and inform our learning and discerning together. iv. Be in the here and now (not mentally somewhere or some time else), with the people who are sharing their time and stories with you. Eliminate any distractions possible.
Fair Use Policy
All program content, recordings, and materials are the intellectual property of The Seattle School and may not be presented, distributed, or replicated. The Seattle School retains the copyright for all recorded content. Some print materials (PDFs, worksheets, journal prompts, etc.) will be licensed under Creative Commons: Attribution NonCommercial ShareAlike. Those materials will be available for download on our website, and may be used as long as the following conditions are met: (1) attribute to the Center for Transforming Engagement even if remixed/modified; (2) do not use for commercial (paid) purposes; and (3) anything you make that remixes or builds upon this material, you must also distribute under Creative Commons. More information on this license is available at creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/
(scroll down and click agree) Full attendance and participation during all sessions are expected to complete the program. Please consider the schedule closely to ensure you will be able to participate in the virtual meetings, and block off your calendar to ensure your attendance. Should you have an emergency (illness, situations out of your control) that will impact your participation please email transforming@theseattleschool.edu Time commitment: Two hours one day per month for 8 months, dates to be determined by majority of registrants' availability and adjusted as needed during the first group meeting. Your feedback is immensely valuable! As an essential component of your participation in this program, we ask that you provide us with your honest, candid, and timely feedback in program surveys and conversations, and consider providing reviews or testimonials of the program for promotional use. 2. Code of Conduct The Center for Transforming Engagement strives for intentionality in the ways we relate to one another - how we as a team relate to each other, how we relate to participants, and how we hope participants will relate to us and one another. To that end, we hold cultural norms about the ways we interact with one another. Your participation in this program is contingent on your agreement to abide by these cultural norms. Confidentiality. For growth to happen, we all need to be able to share about the deeper challenges we face. To provide that atmosphere of openness and support, you commit to not sharing personal information that is shared in program meetings. Curiosity. In our interactions with each other and our communities, we practice the humility of not-knowing that is required to listen and discover. Respect differences. Be aware of different cultural and characterological ways of communicating, and invite others’ voices. Respect theological differences: the river of Christian orthodoxy is wide, and while the streams of that river are distinct, they are not inherently better or worse. Even if you can’t respect the belief, treat the person with respect. You are invited to be a whole person, with both thoughts and feelings. We value both thoughts and feelings as valuable pieces of information that inform one another, and inform our learning and discerning together. Presence. Be in the here and now (not mentally somewhere or some time else), with the people who are sharing their time and stories with you. Eliminate any distractions possible. 3. Fair Use Policy All program content, recordings, and materials are the intellectual property of The Seattle School and may not be presented, distributed, or replicated. The Seattle School retains the copyright for all recorded content. Some print materials (PDFs, worksheets, journal prompts, etc.) will be licensed under Creative Commons: Attribution NonCommercial ShareAlike. Those materials will be available for download on our website, and may be used as long as the following conditions are met: (1) attribute to the Center for Transforming Engagement even if remixed/modified; (2) do not use for commercial (paid) purposes; and (3) anything you make that remixes or builds upon this material, you must also distribute under Creative Commons. More information on this license is available at creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/